JWTruth.orgDokumentierte Vergleichsquelle
Ask JWTruth Suchen
Deutsch

Diese Seite auf

Nur auf Englisch

Alle Sprachen

Autorität und Rechenschaft · Claim record

Am 15. Juni 1911 teilte The Watch Tower seinen Lesern mit, ein Bibelforscher, J. A. Bohnet, werde Saatgut des “miracle wheat” zu einem Dollar je Pfund verkaufen und den gesamten Erlös der Gesellschaft geben; eine Folgemitteilung vom 1. August 1911 berichtete von zahlreichen Bestellungen und nannte Mengenpreise von zweiundzwanzig Pfund für zwanzig Dollar. Ein Dollar je Pfund entspricht den sechzig Dollar je Scheffel, in denen der Vorwurf gegen Russell später formuliert wurde.

Claim ID claim-authority-miracle-wheat-offerConcerns 15. Juni 1911Ausdrückliche Aussage
Ausdrückliche Aussage · 15. Juni 1911 Geprüft

Am 15. Juni 1911 teilte The Watch Tower seinen Lesern mit, ein Bibelforscher, J. A. Bohnet, werde Saatgut des “miracle wheat” zu einem Dollar je Pfund verkaufen und den gesamten Erlös der Gesellschaft geben; eine Folgemitteilung vom 1. August 1911 berichtete von zahlreichen Bestellungen und nannte Mengenpreise von zweiundzwanzig Pfund für zwanzig Dollar. Ein Dollar je Pfund entspricht den sechzig Dollar je Scheffel, in denen der Vorwurf gegen Russell später formuliert wurde. The Watch Tower and Herald of Christ's Presence, 15. Juni 1911The Watch Tower and Herald of Christ's Presence, 1. August 19111975 Yearbook of Jehovah's Witnesses, 1975

Die Position der Organisation oder ihre spätere Erklärung: Das Jahrbuch 1975 sagt, das Saatgut sei von zwei Lesern unter der Bedingung gespendet worden, dass es zu diesem Preis zugunsten der Gesellschaft verkauft werde, die Bruttoeinnahmen hätten etwa 1.800 Dollar betragen, und “Russell himself did not get a penny of this money”.

Belege anzeigen (3 Quellen)
Primärveröffentlichung von Jehovas Zeugen Geprüft

The Watch Tower and Herald of Christ's Presence, “A Donation of Miracle Wheat”

15. Juni 1911 · Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society

“Brother Bohnet writes us that he has gradually accumulated a crop of miracle wheat from the few grains he obtained as a start. He prefers that the first opportunity for obtaining this wheat shall go to The Watch Tower readers. He will sell it for $1 per pound, including postage, and give the entire proceeds to our Society.”

A short notice in the 15 June 1911 issue, giving an address for orders and advising that “miracle wheat should be sowed one-fourth as thick as common wheat” and that “Ordinarily it should produce from ten to fifteen times as much proportionately to the amount sown.”

Scan des Originals

Hinweis zu Herkunft und Überprüfung

Hinweis zur Vertrauensangabe. Read in the Reprints volume for 1911. The notice falls between the issue mastheads for 15 June and 1 July 1911, and the Watch Tower of 1 August 1911 refers back to it as “The notice in The Watch Tower of June 15”. It sits on the Reprints page marked [4843], whose running head is too damaged in this scan’s OCR to be read (“(178-195)”); the nearest legible running heads are [4842] “June 15, 1911 THE WATCH TOWER (190-191)” and [4847] “(202-203)”. No magazine page number is therefore recorded here.

Herkunft des Scans. The Internet Archive item titled “The watch tower and herald of Christ’s presence, 1911” is the Watch Tower Reprints volume for 1911: it reproduces each issue with its masthead, and every page carries a continuous Reprints page number in square brackets together with the original magazine pages in parentheses in the running head. Read in the item’s OCR text file.

Notes. One dollar a pound is sixty dollars a bushel. That is the figure the Brooklyn Daily Eagle and J. J. Ross both used, and the figure the 1975 Yearbook quotes when restating the charge.

Abgerufen. 19. September 2026 · Quellenkennung. src-ctr-wt-1911-0615-miracle-wheat-donation

Primärveröffentlichung von Jehovas Zeugen Geprüft

The Watch Tower and Herald of Christ's Presence, “Miracle Wheat in Demand”

1. August 1911 · Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society

“The notice in The Watch Tower of June 15 that Brother Bohnet has “miracle wheat” in abundance now, and that he will sell it at $1 per pound and donate the entire proceeds to our Tract Fund, has brought in many orders. These will be filled between August 15 and September 1. No limit as to supply has been noted. Sent by Express, prepaid, the price will be twenty-two pounds for $20; fifty-five pounds for $50; larger quantities at the latter rate. The merits of this wheat over the common variety have been mentioned in previous issues of The Watch Tower.”

A follow-up notice reporting demand for the seed and setting bulk prices. It appears in the issue between the mastheads for 1 August and 15 August 1911.

Scan des Originals

Hinweis zu Herkunft und Überprüfung

Hinweis zur Vertrauensangabe. Read in the Reprints volume for 1911. The notice falls between the issue mastheads for 1 August and 15 August 1911, on the Reprints page that ends at the marker [4866]; the running heads on either side are too damaged in this scan’s OCR to yield a magazine page number, so none is recorded.

Herkunft des Scans. The Internet Archive item titled “The watch tower and herald of Christ’s presence, 1911” is the Watch Tower Reprints volume for 1911: it reproduces each issue with its masthead, and every page carries a continuous Reprints page number in square brackets together with the original magazine pages in parentheses in the running head. Read in the item’s OCR text file.

Untermauert durch. src-ctr-wt-1911-0615-miracle-wheat-donation

Abgerufen. 19. September 2026 · Quellenkennung. src-ctr-wt-1911-0801-miracle-wheat-demand

Primärveröffentlichung von Jehovas Zeugen Geprüft

1975 Yearbook of Jehovah's Witnesses, “Part 1—United States of America (“Miracle Wheat”)”

1975 · pp.70-71 · Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society

“his enemies have charged that he sold a great quantity of ordinary wheat seed under the name of “Miracle Wheat” at one dollar per pound, or sixty dollars per bushel. They have held that from this Russell realized an enormous personal profit. However, these charges are absolutely false. ... The wheat was received and sent out by the Society and the gross receipts from it amounted to about $1,800. Russell himself did not get a penny of this money. ... When others criticized this sale, all who had contributed were informed that if they were dissatisfied their money would be returned. In fact, the identical money received for the wheat was held for a year for that purpose. But not one person asked for a refund.”

The Yearbook's account names K. B. Stoner of Fincastle, Virginia as the grower, records the 1907 United States Department of Agriculture report that first drew Russell's attention, and says two Watch Tower readers, J. A. Bohnet and S. J. Fleming, donated about thirty bushels in 1911 on condition it be sold at a dollar a pound for the Society's benefit.

Offizielle Quelle

Hinweis zu Herkunft und Überprüfung

Hinweis zur Vertrauensangabe. Opened on the Watchtower Online Library; page markers 70 and 71 bracket the passage, and the organisation’s own Index 1930-1985 cites this treatment as “yb75 70-71”. The account does not mention the Brooklyn Daily Eagle trial, the jury’s verdict against Russell, the 1915 appeal, or the government seed tests put in evidence at that trial; a full-text search of the Watchtower Online Library returns no occurrence of “Brooklyn Daily Eagle” anywhere in this Yearbook.

Untermauert durch. src-ctr-ad-1915-0507-russell-v-eagle

Notes. The Yearbook says the donors gave “about thirty bushels”; Russell’s own account in The Watch Tower of 15 February 1913 says “the total amount being twenty bushels”. The discrepancy is on the record and neither figure should be published as settled.

Abgerufen. 19. September 2026 · Quellenkennung. src-ctr-yb-1975-p70-miracle-wheat

Seite zur Aussage Berichtigen oder aktualisieren

A direct link to this claim is https://jwtruth.org/de/evidence/claim-authority-miracle-wheat-offer/. Every source above opens the original document or the best available copy. If you believe the wording, date or context is wrong, report an error.