ClaimRace, women and healthverified1960sExplicit statement

Race, femmes et santé · Claim record

La Tour de Garde du 15 mars 1964 disait aux femmes que, dans la congrégation, une sœur 'would not be found debating with brothers or publicly criticizing them', et que, si un homme donnait une mauvaise réponse à une réunion, elle pouvait citer le paragraphe imprimé mais 'neither by her comment nor by her tone of voice would she be critical of the brother's answer'. L'article ajoutait qu'il vaudrait mieux que le conducteur interroge plutôt d'autres hommes, afin d'éviter de l'embarrasser.

Claim ID claim-attitudes-1964-woman-not-to-correct-a-manConcerns 15 mars 1964Déclaration explicite

L’affirmation et ses preuves

Déclaration explicite · 15 mars 1964 Vérifié

La Tour de Garde du 15 mars 1964 disait aux femmes que, dans la congrégation, une sœur 'would not be found debating with brothers or publicly criticizing them', et que, si un homme donnait une mauvaise réponse à une réunion, elle pouvait citer le paragraphe imprimé mais 'neither by her comment nor by her tone of voice would she be critical of the brother's answer'. L'article ajoutait qu'il vaudrait mieux que le conducteur interroge plutôt d'autres hommes, afin d'éviter de l'embarrasser. Source: The Watchtower, 15 mars 1964

Position de l’organisation ou explication ultérieure : Le même article déclarait que les femmes partagent l'espérance céleste à égalité avec les hommes, quoique 'not as women, but as glorious spirit creatures'. La Tour de Garde de 2024 demande aux anciens de solliciter l'avis des femmes et de les écouter attentivement lorsqu'elles parlent.

Afficher les preuves (1 source)
Publication primaire des Témoins de Jéhovah Vérifié

The Watchtower, “The Privileges of the Christian Woman”

15 mars 1964 · pp.178-183 · pars. 11-12 · Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society

“Where a wrong comment is offered by a male person in the audience, during the Watchtower study for example, this does not require the sister if called on to follow along and make her comment agree with the incorrect thought given. But neither by her comment nor by her tone of voice would she be critical of the brother's answer.”

The article sets out what a woman may and may not do in the congregation. It explains that 'keep silent in the congregations' does not mean total silence, but that 'a sister would not be found debating with brothers or publicly criticizing them, either at a meeting or to other members of the congregation at other times, nor would she exercise authority over the brothers as a teacher or instructor'. It adds that if other mature men are present it would be better for the conductor to call on them instead, and 'thus avoid any possible embarrassment'.

Note de provenance et de vérification for The Watchtower, The Privileges of the Christian Woman

Note sur la fiabilité. The full article was fetched from the Watchtower Online Library on 19 September 2026 and read. The quoted paragraph 12 falls between the library's page markers for pages 181 and 182, so it is on p. 181. The citation code inside the document reads 'w64 3/15 pp. 178-183'.

Notes. The same article states that 'no woman could serve as a Levite priest', that women who share the heavenly hope do so in a way that 'would not be as women, but as glorious spirit creatures in the heavens', and that God 'takes into account the sex distinction as to service arrangements in his organization'. Earlier paragraphs describe the wife's role largely in terms of the home: 'A home that is kept clean, neat and orderly is usually a testimony to the fact that here lives a capable wife.'

Date de consultation. 19 septembre 2026 · Identifiant de la source. src-wom-w-1964-0315-privileges-christian-woman

Page de l’affirmation Corriger ou mettre à jour

A direct link to this claim is https://jwtruth.org/fr/evidence/claim-attitudes-1964-woman-not-to-correct-a-man/. Every source above opens the original document or the best available copy. If you believe the wording, date or context is wrong, report an error.