ClaimRace, women and healthverified1970sExplicit statement

Raça, mulheres e saúde · Claim record

Uma resposta de Perguntas dos Leitores de 15 de abril de 1975 dizia que consultar um psiquiatra 'is a matter for personal decision', mas perguntava, a respeito das crenças dos psiquiatras: 'Would you want to mold your life according to the thinking of men who view matters in this manner?'; aconselhava que 'if a Witness does consult such he should carefully scrutinize any treatment recommended' e encaminhava os leitores que tivessem 'feelings of hostility or despondency' aos anciãos da congregação, conforme Tiago 5:13-16.

Claim ID claim-attitudes-psychiatry-1975-personal-decisionConcerns 15 de abril de 1975Declaração explícita

A afirmação e as suas provas

Declaração explícita · 15 de abril de 1975 Verificado

Uma resposta de Perguntas dos Leitores de 15 de abril de 1975 dizia que consultar um psiquiatra 'is a matter for personal decision', mas perguntava, a respeito das crenças dos psiquiatras: 'Would you want to mold your life according to the thinking of men who view matters in this manner?'; aconselhava que 'if a Witness does consult such he should carefully scrutinize any treatment recommended' e encaminhava os leitores que tivessem 'feelings of hostility or despondency' aos anciãos da congregação, conforme Tiago 5:13-16. Source: The Watchtower, 15 de abril de 1975

A posição da organização ou explicação posterior: A mesma resposta dizia que as Testemunhas de Jeová 'do not categorically rule out the possibility of treatment by doctors specializing in emotional or mental problems' e que 'the final decision is his own'.

Mostrar as provas (1 fonte)
Publicação primária das Testemunhas de Jeová Verificado

The Watchtower, “Questions From Readers”

15 de abril de 1975 · pp.255-256 · Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania

“Whether a Christian will consult a psychiatrist, or any other doctor, is a matter for personal decision. ... So, while Jehovah's witnesses do not categorically rule out the possibility of treatment by doctors specializing in emotional or mental problems, if a Witness does consult such he should carefully scrutinize any treatment recommended.”

A ruling answering the question 'Do Jehovah's witnesses feel that it is proper to consult a psychiatrist?' It notes that many analysts are atheists or agnostics, cites a study in which over half agreed with Freud that belief in God was 'infantile', and asks: 'Would you want to mold your life according to the thinking of men who view matters in this manner?' It directs readers with 'feelings of hostility or despondency' to the congregation elders under James 5:13-16, and suggests that uncertainty about a therapy 'may' be discussed with elders, 'although the final decision is his own'.

Nota de procedência e verificação for The Watchtower, Questions From Readers

Nota de confiança. Full item read on the Watchtower Online Library on 19 September 2026; the page markers in the page's own HTML place it on pages 255-256. The ellipsis marks an omission of about 700 words between the opening sentence and the closing summary.

Notes. A Questions From Readers item rather than a feature article. It does not forbid psychiatric care.

Consultado em. 19 de setembro de 2026 · Identificador da fonte. src-hlth-w-1975-0415-qfr-psychiatrist

Página da afirmação Corrigir ou atualizar

A direct link to this claim is https://jwtruth.org/pt-br/evidence/claim-attitudes-psychiatry-1975-personal-decision/. Every source above opens the original document or the best available copy. If you believe the wording, date or context is wrong, report an error.